For me...
Alum
Witch Hazel usually generic unscented but I have some Thayer Lavender (teetotaler version)
Then either a Balm or an AS but not both.
Although I occasionally use my Stirling Unscented Balm and toss some of The Veg on when I'm feeling particularly frisky.
Winter or Summer same routine.. I'm boring, I know.
Balm vs aftershave splash