I shaved with the Caribbean Bay Rum yesterday and I didn't thing it smelled like bay rum at all. It didn't smell like any of the bay rums I've smelled before, but it did have a nice soft after smell that lasted for maybe about a hour. For me this one is a keeper. I tried the Tiffany for men and it is a nice fragrance, but very light almost not there at all. I would say it's like a woman with a nice light for whispering. This is a keeper for me also. I'll have to go back to my samples to see which ones I decided to keep and post them here.
Sampling Mama Bears Soaps