Almost out of AS

So, I'm almost out of Nivea Cooling Balm, and I'm thinking of trying some new balm. When I bought my first DE razor at AOS, I picked up their sandalwood kit, and I really like the smell of it, but the AS balm doesn't seem to do much for my razor burn, whereas the Nivea did.

I'm tempted to go back and buy some more Nivea, but I'd love to find some other balms or milks that are comparable, if for nothing else than to try them out. I'm definitely trying to stay away from anything that has alcohol in it, not for the burn, but because it dries out my skin like crazy and I end up looking like a blotchy, scaly mess.

Anyone have any recommendations? I'd prefer something sandalwood scented, since it smells great to me and I feel like I've just stepped into the offices of Sterling Cooper Draper Price, but I'm open to any other "manly" type scents (Aqua Velva and Brut are out, though - the wife hates the smell).

Thanks in advance!

Almost out of AS